Wineberry Shirley Temple with Spicebush Grenadine

Reimagining the electric red drink of our youth

Posted by Carolyn Dugas on July 26, 2020 · 6 minute read

Fresh and foraged newsletter signup

*Zip code is collected to notify you of local events

Jump to Recipe

Wineberry Shirley Temple

I grew up sipping on sickly sweet Shirley Temples that stained the tongue the shade of Red Lake #40. Every time the adults busted out their exclusive 'adult-only beverages' my sister and I would fashion a little drink of our own, one that no adult would dare sip for fear of a perma-red ring forming around their lips. A splash of 7-Up, a swig of electric red grenadine, and as many maraschino cherries as our grubby fingers could fish out of the jar - this was the recipe for our ultimate kids-only drink.

This summer, as I longed for the days of my youth (minus the inevitable crash from the sugar-high) I dreamt of a Shirley Temple with a natural red hue that was bursting with the flavors of the wild. I schemed and plotted in anticipation of wineberry season, sure that July would bring the perfect replacement for the maraschino cherry. With the cherry replacement down, all I needed was a newfangled grenadine to splash over some seltzer water, but I struggled to find the right recipe.

Spiceberry grenadine

I stumbled upon just the grenadine I sought in This is Camino, a cookbook about a seed-to-stem restaurant out in California. I had tried several grenadine recipes before but was unsatisfied with their high sugar levels and lack of flavor. This recipe, however, relied on reduced pomegranate juice to create a depth that you just can't get from red sugar water. The Word Nerd part of me was pleased as well - the name grenadine comes from the French word grenade, or pomegranate, which was the original base of the syrup.

Once I had the base recipe down I decided to swap out the conventional orange peel for some spiceberries, the fruit of Lindera benzoin. I often think of spiceberries as Orange-Plus or even Warm Spice-Plus. Spiceberries have notes of citrus, allspice, clove, and more, all packaged in one teeny tiny berry. I added just enough to give the grenadine a mysterious note, but not so much that it overpowered the pomegranate.

Freshly gathered wineberries

Once wineberry season rolled around, I gathered up some of the sticky-sweet fruits to figure out the best way to finish off my foraged Shirley Temple. The first attempt, lightly muddled wineberries, left me with a mouth full of seeds, cursing the fact that I had just used my last piece of floss. This led me to try juicing them. Despite their minute stature, the wineberry packs a hefty flavor punch, so even just pressing a small handful through a strainer yielded enough juice for a single Shirley Temple.

With that, my creation was complete! Sipping happily on my patio, it felt like I had done my best to transform my childhood nostalgia through the lens of the wild realities of my current life. I can only imagine how my summers would have been had I sipped on wineberry Shirley Temples as a child instead of a drink more suited for a hummingbird feeder.

Wineberry Shirley Temple

Wineberry Shirley Temple Recipe

You can easily scale this recipe to serve a crowd.

  • Makes: 1 small glass
  • Active time: 5 minutes

Wineberry Shirley Temple Ingredients

  • Small handful of wineberries (about 20 berries)
  • 6 ounces unflavored sparkling water, chilled
  • 2 teaspoons spicebush grenadine (recipe below)
  • Wineberries for garnish

Wineberry Shirley Temple Instructions

  1. Extract the juice from the wineberries by mashing them with a spoon against a fine mesh sieve set over a bowl. Pour the juice into your serving glass. Discard the seeds (don't compost them!).
  2. Pour in the sparkling water and grenadine and give everything a good stir. Add some ice if you would like and garnish with a few wineberries!

Spicebush Grenadine Recipe

A tart and deeply flavored grenadine syrup with a hint of the wild. Be sure to use 100% pomegranate juice for the best flavor. This grenadine is also great in alcoholic drinks such as Tequila Sunrises or Hurricanes! The recipe is adapted from This is Camino.

  • Makes: 1 ½ cups grenadine
  • Active time: 5 minutes
  • Inactive time: 30 minutes

Spicebush Grenadine Ingredients

  • 2 cups pomegranate juice
  • ½ cup sugar
  • 1 Tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
  • 10 spicebush berries, crushed (fresh or frozen)

Spicebush Grenadine Instructions

  1. Bring the pomegranate juice to a boil in a small saucepan, then reduce the heat and simmer for about 15-20 minutes, or until the liquid is reduced to 1 cup. If you accidentally reduce it too far, just add enough hot water to bring the total volume back up to 1 cup.
  2. Remove the saucepan from the heat and stir the sugar, lemon juice, and spiceberries until the sugar is completely dissolved.
  3. Steep for 10 minutes then strain out the spiceberries. Pour into a clean bottle and store in the fridge where it should last for a few weeks.

Spicebush Grenadine Recipe Notes & Substitutions

For juicing larger quantities of wineberries, you can use a potato ricer lined with cheesecloth, or a food mill.

You can replace the spiceberries with half of the peel from a medium-sized orange.

Pomegranate Love Grenade "Pomegranate Love Grenade" illustration courtesy of Studio Gooz
Carolyn Dugas, Forager


Carolyn was born and raised in the woods of New England, where she attempted to feed "moss smoothies" to unsuspecting strangers as a child. Mercifully, her wild food skills have improved since then, thanks in part to a year-long foraging apprenticeship in 2017. Since then, she has been collecting and preparing wild foods on a daily basis. Learn more here.

More Spicebush Posts